Judges Doubted Her Song Choice, Until Her Voice Left Them Speechless

At just twelve years old, singer-songwriter Grace VanderWaal gave the world a glimpse of her talent at her 2016 America’s Got Talent audition. Standing on stage, she confidently announced, “I’m performing my own song tonight because I think it really shows who I am.” Born in Kansas and living in New York, Grace had big dreams, adding, “Hopefully. I’m hoping it does.”

And, as it turned out, those hopes were well-placed.

Grace’s incredible audition instantly earned her comparisons to Taylor Swift, and her performance set her on a glittering path to success. In the end, she took home the $1 million prize and won Season 11 of AGT.

Grace VanderWaal’s First Audition on AGT

When Judge Simon Cowell asked Grace if she believed she could win, she responded with a smile, “Miracles can happen, so maybe.” And when he inquired about the song she’d be performing, Grace simply said, “It’s about me,” revealing that most of her school friends “don’t really know I sing.”

Accompanied by her ukulele, Grace captivated the audience with “I Don’t Know My Name,” a soulful, personal song about discovering one’s identity. As she sang, “I don’t play by the rules of the game. You say I’m just trying, just trying,” her unique voice and honest lyrics resonated with everyone watching.

The Judges’ Reactions

As Grace finished her song, the room fell silent with anticipation. Howie Mandel was the first to speak, declaring, “This show is about surprises. You called yourself a miracle, and I believe you are a living, breathing miracle.”

He also praised her originality, referencing her lyrics and saying, “People might not know your name yet, but they will now.” Then, to Grace’s surprise, he hit the Golden Buzzer, sending her straight into the live shows. With tears of joy streaming down her face, Grace hugged Howie, who told her, “You are amazing.”

Simon Cowell then shared his thoughts, comparing her songwriting talent to that of a pop star. “Grace, do you know what I see in your future? You could be the next Taylor Swift,” he predicted, clearly impressed.

Heidi Klum echoed his sentiment, saying, “That was truly amazing,” while Mel B remarked on Grace’s uniqueness.

As the crowd erupted in applause, Simon turned to Howie and said, “I think we’ve found a star,” playfully admitting he was “annoyed” he hadn’t been the one to hit the Golden Buzzer.

After skyrocketing to fame from her unforgettable America’s Got Talent audition, Grace VanderWaal has expanded her career into acting, starring as the lead in Stargirl and continuing to make waves in the music industry with multiple album releases. Now, she’s set to take on a new role as a pop star in Francis Ford Coppola’s upcoming film, Megalopolis, showcasing her ever-evolving talent on the big screen.

Catch Grace’s rise to stardom by streaming past seasons of America’s Got Talent on Peacock. Don’t forget to share this inspiring story with friends and family, and we’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below!