‘American Idol’ fans on social media have already chosen their favorites Jamal Roberts and John Foster are stealing hearts online and leading the fan buzz.

American Idol is deep into its 23rd season, and while the finale is still a few weeks away, fans online think they already know who the finalists will be.

Social media is buzzing with support for Jamal Roberts and John Foster, with many viewers calling them the clear frontrunners. One fan wrote, “Based on Facebook likes… it looks like John and Jamal will be top 2. Winner is still a toss-up.”

Ladies Night and Star Mentors

Season 23 kicked off in March, and this year’s contestants have been mentored by big names like Jelly Roll, Fantasia Barrino, Ashanti, and Josh Groban. As of now, we’re down to the Top 10, and on May 4, fans can look forward to a themed episode: “Ladies Night,” with Miranda Lambert as the guest mentor.

Jamal vs. John: The Internet’s Favorites

Jamal Roberts has been stealing the spotlight for weeks, especially with fans who remember him from Sunday Best, a gospel singing competition. His recent performance of The Isley Brothers left Lionel Richie visibly moved—and the surprise family reunion that followed had fans in tears.

Meanwhile, John Foster is gaining momentum thanks to his classic country sound and undeniable stage presence. But he’s also had to deal with a few rumors online—some fans questioning his background, age, and even whether his popularity is driven more by social media than talent.

Still, others are firmly in his corner. One fan commented:
“He has that smooth George Strait–Conway Twitty voice you just don’t hear on the radio anymore. Even my wife, who doesn’t like country, wants John to win now.”

Not Everyone Agrees…

Despite the hype around John and Jamal, fans haven’t completely ruled out other contestants.

Some pointed out:

• “The John love is shocking. I thought Slater would be the frontrunner in that lane.”

• “I think Gabby SHOULD win, but I’ll be happy with either John or Jamal.”

• “I’d be fine with anyone but Breanna or Josh winning.”

• “John is almost as good as Slater… But really, every contestant reminds me of someone from a past season.”

As American Idol edges closer to its finale, one thing’s for sure: the race is tight, and fan opinions are louder than ever.

Who’s got your vote—Jamal, John, or someone else entirely? Drop your pick in the comments!