Carrie Underwood Stuns in Her ‘American Idol’ Finale Dress—20 Years Later!

Carrie Underwood brought some serious nostalgia to American Idol this week — and fans are loving every second of it!

On Monday, April 28, American Idol hosted a special night celebrating “iconic Idol moments,” with the Top 12 contestants performing songs made famous during past seasons. It was a tribute to the show’s legacy, with touching nods to fan-favorite performances from years gone by.

Slater Nalley sang John Prine’s “Angel from Montgomery,” a song previously performed by Megan Danielle in Season 21. Meanwhile, country standout John Foster took on “I Told You So,” the same tune Carrie Underwood once sang in a duet with Randy Travis.

But the real showstopper moment came from Carrie herself — and it wasn’t just her voice that stole the spotlight.

Carrie Underwood Brings Back Her Legendary Finale Dress

The night before, on Sunday, April 27, Underwood performed Heart’s “Alone” — a powerhouse number she originally sang during her own season of Idol in 2005. And then, on Monday, she went full throwback by slipping into the dress — the dazzling, bedazzled leopard-print gown she wore the night she won Season 4.

Yes, that dress. Nearly two decades later, it still fits like a glove.

Now serving as a judge on Season 23, Underwood gave fans a total “full circle” moment by rewearing her finale dress. She even shared a playful video of herself in it on social media with the caption, “Same dress, different view.”

Fans Are Loving the Nostalgia

Longtime fans flooded her post with love, memories, and disbelief:

• “Carrie, as a 12-year-old, I voted for you 84 times on finale night. You’re welcome!”

• “Love all the Idol memory throwbacks!!”

• “I’m living for all these throwbacks. Feels like such a full circle moment.”

• “How many women can wear the same dress from 20 years ago? Not many.”

• “Voted for you every single week too.”

• “That’s crazy!!!!!”

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood)

It’s safe to say Carrie Underwood just delivered one of the most heartwarming and iconic moments of the season — and reminded everyone exactly why she’s still America’s idol.

Do you remember watching Carrie win back in 2005?